Environment

US Coal Ash Landfills Threaten Ohio Waterways and Residents

US Coal Ash Landfills Threaten Ohio Waterways and Residents

Rural communities along the Ohio River in Clermont County are grappling with severe environmental and health concerns stemming from legacy coal ash landfills. Residents Brian and Rhonda Brittain, whose property abuts Little Indian Creek near a massive 1,400-acre landfill, report persistent sulfuric odors and worry over hazardous waste contaminating local water sources that flow directly into the Ohio River, a drinking water supply for millions in Cincinnati and Louisville.

Groundwater Contamination and Public Health Risks

In consecutive rounds of testing conducted this year and previously, reporting from landfill owner Dynegy Zimmer LLC—a subsidiary of Vistra Corp—revealed statistically significant levels of lithium exceeding applicable groundwater protection standards. While coal-fired power plants have been phased out, their residual material, including ash, boiler slag, and silica, contains dangerous constituents capable of causing cancer and neurological illnesses.

Local health data reflects these hazards, showing a lung and bronchus cancer incidence rate of 69.6 per 100,000 residents in Clermont County, well above the national rate of 51.8 per 100,000. In neighboring Hamilton County, the rate sits at 62 per 100,000.

Thom Cmar, an attorney at the environmental protection nonprofit Earthjustice, explained that the Zimmer site operates as a legacy landfill exempt from modern safety and design standards. Cmar noted that the facility was constructed without barriers to prevent coal ash waste from contacting groundwater, and added that states with strong coal industries have historically allowed utilities to take the lead in setting safety standards.

Further along the Ohio River, the shuttered William H. Zimmer power plant and the closed Beckjord coal plant have left behind severe pollution issues. County administrators are currently suing former operator Duke Energy and current owner Commercial Liability Partners after heavy metals were detected in at least 20 water wells over a 12-year period. Unlined holding ponds at Beckjord contain billions of pounds of toxins, prompting residents to abandon tap water and forcing county authorities to face a $30m bill for a new water treatment plant.

Vistra Corp, a Texas-headquartered energy giant, has faced numerous fines and lawsuits nationwide for market manipulation, chemical fires, and pollution violations. Jenny Lyon, speaking for Vistra Corp, stated that coal ash is no longer dumped at the Zimmer site, noting that the facility has accepted inert, limestone-based byproducts from the Miami Fort power plant since 2007. Lyon also mentioned that the company has invested in systems to minimize odors, acknowledging resident concerns.

Beyond environmental worries, locals report that Dynegy Zimmer has amassed dozens of property parcels totaling more than 3,400 acres in Washington township. Rhonda Brittain pointed out that property devaluations forced local schools, libraries, and other entities in Clermont County to repay $139,000 to Vistra Corp in 2023 after successful appeals.

Emails sent by Environment | The Guardian to the Ohio Environmental Protection Agency regarding independent testing inside the Zimmer landfill went unanswered. Meanwhile, residents like the Brittains continue their push for accountability, demanding that energy companies allocate resources to remediate the contamination.

You May Also Like

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *