Environment

UK Green Legal Protections Under Threat, Lawyers Warn

UK Green Legal Protections Under Threat, Lawyers Warn

The UK government is considering stripping back legal protections that limit the costs community groups face when challenging planning decisions that threaten nature, according to environmental lawyers. Exclusive reporting by The Guardian reveals that the Ministry of Justice has been holding private meetings with select stakeholders on plans that could distance the UK from the Aarhus convention.

The Aarhus convention is an environmental treaty signed into law by the UK in 2005 that guarantees the legal right to participate in democratic processes on environmental matters such as sewage pollution, new roads, or datacentre developments. Under this treaty, individuals bringing an environmental legal claim are protected by a cost cap requiring them to pay only £5,000 of the other side’s costs if they lose, while the protection for organisations is set at £10,000. This framework ensures that environmental legal challenges are not prohibitively expensive for individuals and public interest groups.

Other possible changes discussed in the private meetings include doubling cost caps at each stage of a challenge and removing cost protections if a court finds a misuse of judicial review. An additional proposal would allow groups that crowdfund their legal challenges to face costs of up to 70% of the money they raise if they lose. Proposals to alter environmental judicial reviews began under Keir Starmer’s government, which has frequently referred to nature as a blocker to growth. Starmer previously singled out activist Dr Andrew Boswell as an example of nimble and zealot figures bringing vexatious legal claims that thwart growth, referencing a two-year legal fight against the expansion of the A47 in Norfolk that Boswell ultimately lost.

Boswell stated that Starmer was putting a target on his back and noted that his campaign against the A47, which was funded by £73,000 in crowdsourcing from 2,000 individuals, brought the community together in Norfolk. Carol Day, a senior environmental solicitor at Leigh Day, told The Guardian that the proposed changes would bring environmental litigation almost to a halt. Day added that the government lacks hard and fast evidence of legal action holding things up to justify such a discussion. Another environmental lawyer told The Guardian that the proposed changes would fundamentally undermine access to environmental justice deliberately and mean potentially really terrible decisions would not be challenged.

Impact on Grassroots Campaigners and Organizations

Local community objectors are often at the cutting edge of challenges that expose widespread government failures regarding national and international obligations, according to the lawyer. Sarah Finch, an environmental campaigner whose grassroots judicial review over an oil well in Surrey changed UK climate law, stated that the government’s proposals would have prevented her group from bringing their case. Finch told The Guardian that they never would have brought the legal action running the risk of paying the other side’s fees, calling it completely despicable for the government to take this right away.

Lawyers fear these private meetings signal that the government is accelerating toward leaving the convention, a claim the government denies. Day remarked that while the UK government says it does not want to leave the convention, the potential changes would put them in a very difficult position of being significantly non-compliant with it. Kyle Lischak, the head of the environmental law charity ClientEarth UK, stated that the right to challenge unlawful decisions is one of the few ways people can hold those in power to account. Lischak added that whether regarding datacentres or intensive livestock production, people too often find their rights and environment on the chopping block in favour of rapid industrial buildout, requiring a safe and affordable route to court.

Niall Toru, a senior lawyer at Friends of the Earth, stated that the government seems determined to find someone to blame for slow growth while environmental campaigners and community groups make an easy target, emphasizing that nature is not holding the economy back whereas floods, droughts, pollution, and climate breakdown are costing billions. Toru noted that these proposals will not fix those problems and will instead make more people feel that decisions are being imposed on them without meaningful ways to challenge them.

A government spokesperson stated that the administration remains committed to upholding its obligations under the Aarhus convention, including maintaining access to environmental justice that is not prohibitively expensive, and confirmed there are no plans to remove costs protections for well-founded claims.

You May Also Like

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *