Table of Contents
During recent discussions in Abu Dhabi aimed at ending the war in Ukraine, Russian representatives reportedly presented a document outlining significant demands. As reported by The New York Times, the document, dated November 10, calls for an end to Western arms shipments to Ukraine and demands that NATO withdraw its military presence to the borders that existed in 1997.
The Significance of 1997
The year 1997 represents the state of the NATO alliance prior to its first eastward expansion. At that time, the alliance consisted of 16 member states. While Poland, Hungary, and the Czech Republic had been invited to join, they did not formally become members until 1999. Since then, the alliance has grown to include 32 member states across North America and Europe. The Russian proposal does not explicitly demand that Central and Eastern European nations leave the alliance, but rather that NATO remove its military infrastructure and troops from those territories.
Consequences of a NATO Withdrawal
Removing NATO forces from member states that joined after 1997 would severely impact their defense capabilities. For instance, NATO has provided air policing for Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania since 2004, as these nations lack their own fighter jets. Furthermore, the planned deployment of a German brigade to Lithuania, expected to be operational by 2027, would be halted. In Romania, the Mihail Kogalniceanu Air Base is currently being expanded to potentially become the largest NATO air base in Europe.
Leaders from NATO’s eastern flank have strongly rejected these demands. Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk told TVP World that they would not allow new security rules to be established “over the heads of Poland and Europe.” Bulgarian Prime Minister Rumen Radev described the proposal as “unthinkable and unrealistic,” while Estonian Prime Minister Kristen Michal stated that there is nothing to discuss regarding Europe’s security order, asserting that it is currently functioning well.
The Role of Mutual Defense
Article 5 of the NATO treaty mandates that members assist one another in the event of an armed attack. The effectiveness of this clause relies on the perception that NATO can intervene quickly. The presence of allied troops along the eastern flank is intended to serve as a deterrent. A withdrawal could lead Russia to perceive an attack on NATO territory as carrying fewer risks, thereby complicating regional defense.
Alliances and Historical Context
European nations have historically agreed that states maintain the freedom to choose their own alliances, a principle enshrined in Article 10 of NATO’s founding treaty and the 1990 Charter of Paris. While Russia has previously pointed to remarks made by Western officials during German reunification negotiations as evidence of an informal promise to limit expansion, no legally binding agreement was ever signed to prevent NATO from including former Warsaw Pact countries.
The 1997 NATO-Russia Founding Act established that both sides would no longer view each other as adversaries and confirmed that Moscow held no veto power over NATO decisions. Additionally, the 1994 Budapest Memorandum saw Russia, the U.S., and the U.K. commit to respecting Ukraine’s borders in exchange for the country giving up its nuclear weapons, though this agreement did not include military defense obligations.
Motivations Behind the Demands
Russia previously submitted similar draft treaties to the U.S. and NATO in late 2021, shortly before the full-scale invasion of Ukraine. By linking the war in Ukraine to broader negotiations over NATO’s military footprint, Moscow seeks to gain leverage and address what it describes as the “root causes” of the conflict. Currently, no major Western power has indicated a willingness to accept these terms. Former Polish intelligence coordinator Stanislaw Zaryn suggested that the talks may be an attempt by Russia to gain time and undermine Western unity ahead of future confrontations.







