The debate over who is Chelsea’s most important player has been reignited among fans following recent poor results during the absence of Brazil striker Joao Pedro. The 25-year-old will miss the upcoming home match against Leeds United due to a thigh injury after Chelsea lost three of their previous four games without him.
Managerial challenges and squad cover
Following a 2-0 home defeat by Tottenham during this run, manager Xabi Alonso faced criticism regarding his team’s identity and personnel choices when trying to replace Joao Pedro. Danny Welbeck, signed from Brighton over the summer, has started only one Premier League match during the injury layoff. Pedro Neto has twice played through the middle, Morgan Rogers started centrally against Tottenham, and Emmanuel Emegha has battled fitness issues of his own following his arrival from Strasbourg.
The ongoing absence of Joao Pedro proves costly ahead of a busy winter period, leaving fifth-placed Chelsea 11 points behind league leaders Arsenal. Having secured a new contract until 2034 and the number nine shirt in August, the club views the £55m signing as central to Alonso’s plans. Discussing the team’s goalscoring challenges without the forward, Alonso stated that the entire squad must contribute through set-pieces from defenders and midfielders as well as teamwork.
Statistical impact of Joao Pedro’s absence
Data from the Premier League demonstrates a sharp decline in Chelsea’s attacking output when Joao Pedro is unavailable. Since the start of the 2025-26 season, Chelsea’s goals per game drop from 1.8 with the Brazilian to 0.6 without him, while expected goals fall from 1.8 to 1.1. Shots on target decrease from 4.8 to 3.9 per match, and the team fails to score in 71.4% of games without him compared to 12.2% with him.
Match results reflect these attacking struggles, with Chelsea’s points-per-game average falling from 1.5 to 0.9 in his absence. Furthermore, teammates such as Cole Palmer and Morgan Rogers experience a notable decrease in goal output when playing without the forward. While the debate over his status as the squad’s vital player continues, the statistics indicate that Chelsea’s points return with him aligns with Champions League qualification, unlike their form without him.








