Within a 24-hour period, two of Donald Trump’s administration nominees suffered sudden setbacks, with the White House withdrawing its pick for the Food and Drug Administration and the Senate halting a vote on a National Science Foundation nominee.
FDA Nomination Withdrawn
Late Tuesday evening, Axios reported that the White House abruptly dropped its controversial choice of Heidi Overton to lead the FDA. Overton, who served as a top conservative domestic policy aide in the White House, faced criticism and skepticism from both Republican and Democrats regarding her positions on birth control, vapes, abortion, and vaccines. While Overton opposes abortion, some Republicans felt her stance was not strong enough, while Democrats were troubled by her support for Trump and Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s criticized anti-vaccine statements and policies.
During her September confirmation hearing, Overton repeatedly stonewalled senators, declining to give direct answers even to basic questions from supportive Republicans, which frustrated lawmakers across the political spectrum. Among the topics she avoided were the FDA’s safety review of the abortion pill mifepristone, which extensive data demonstrates is extremely safe. She also declined to state whether she agreed with Trump’s false claims that children receive vaccine doses the “size of a soda bottle” or that the measles vaccine is “quite lethal,” and she repeatedly refused to answer if Trump could ever be wrong.
Axios quoted a senior Trump administration official who explained that Overton’s nomination was canceled because she “lacks the support on the Hill to move forward with her confirmation.”
Senate Committee Reaction
The Senate’s Health, Education, Labor and Pensions (HELP) Committee, led by Republican Senator Bill Cassidy of Louisiana, had planned to vote on Overton’s nomination on Wednesday. Following the withdrawal late Tuesday, Cassidy stated on social media that he initially believed she maintained a “viable confirmation path.” However, he added that the nomination was “abandoned” after several anti-abortion senators demanded commitments from her that they were unable to secure. Cassidy stated that the administration chose to withdraw Dr. Overton instead of providing those commitments.








