San Diego’s city council voted on Monday evening to terminate its contracts with surveillance equipment vendors Flock and Ubicquia, making it one of the largest cities to sever ties with the valuation-heavy startup Flock.
Surveillance Opposition and Council Decision
Lilly Irani, speaking in her personal capacity as a member of the Transparent and Responsible Use of Surveillance Technology (TRUST) SD Coalition, celebrated the outcome. Local critics have spent recent years loudly opposing the technology, and Irani credited the victory to national energy that fostered diverse political coalitions. She highlighted that a crucial shift occurred last month when councilmember Stephen Whitburn withdrew his support, enabling a political majority to halt the surveillance programs.
During an October press conference explaining his prior stance, Whitburn stated that he wanted local residents to feel secure. He noted that if the camera systems caused many citizens to feel insecure, they had failed as public safety instruments.
Reactions from City Leadership and Vendors
Following the council’s vote, San Diego Mayor Todd Gloria announced on social media that he respected the legislative decision and would not veto the action to halt camera operations citywide.
As reported by Ars Technica, Flock spokesperson Andrew Smith stated via email that the firm also respected the municipality’s choice, though he expressed displeasure with the outcome. Smith argued that removing a tool actively aiding in violent crime resolution causes public safety to regress, leading to slower case resolutions, increased retail theft, delayed recovery of missing children, and delayed justice for victims.








