The Verge receives dozens of daily press releases from brands ahead of the biggest shopping day of the year in the US, hoping to publicize their holiday offers. Most companies prefer to avoid researching whether their promotions are actually worthwhile, leading to widespread confusion for consumers trying to find genuine savings.
Investigating Unclear Retailer Promotions
Research published by the Groundwork Collaborative regarding Amazon’s deal displays highlights how confusing shopping indicators can be. Their researchers tracked products ahead of Black Friday and Cyber Monday in 2024 and 2025, claiming that nearly one in three products advertised as deals on Amazon did not offer savings during the actual events. Furthermore, the investigation found that nearly a tenth of the examined deals were more expensive during sales events than on certain days in the preceding month.
As reported by The Verge, a common issue involves good deals featuring inflated discount claims, where original retail list prices are set higher than normal day-to-day prices to create the illusion of substantial savings. In a statement provided to investigative journalist Ronan Farrow, an unattributed Amazon spokesperson explained that its list price can aggregate prices from the past 90 to 180 days rather than just 30 days, drawing from Amazon and competing retailers. However, the publication notes that confusing pricing strategies extend far beyond a single platform.
The Selection and Vetting Process
Vetting promotions is a major part of the daily routine for The Verge staff, and most pitched items never make it to the site because they fail to meet strict standards. While a product must be something the team has tested and genuinely enjoys as a core requirement, that endorsement alone does not guarantee coverage. The publication frequently skips offers that feature mediocre discounts, recur weekly, last only a few hours, require a premium membership, or originate from unfamiliar retailers.
Recent market changes have further complicated pricing evaluations, as higher tariffs and memory price increases have substantially impacted item costs. For products affected by recent price hikes, new promotional prices often match or come close to original sticker prices. To help monitor genuine price drops, the team utilizes independent free tracking tools such as CamelCamelCamel and Keepa, alongside Amazon’s Alexa for Shopping tool. Out of thousands of options evaluated ahead of the holidays, only a carefully curated selection of tested items across categories like headphones, televisions, and smart home tech ultimately appears on the site.








