Table of Contents
A nationwide study has concluded that prohibiting cellphones in classrooms leads to modest but significant improvements in student learning. Researchers from Harvard University and Dartmouth College, in collaboration with the academic assessment group NWEA, found that such bans provide an academic benefit equivalent to adding one to two weeks of instruction to the school year.
Impact of In-School Bans
The research team analyzed testing data from 3.3 million students across 4,600 schools between the 2021–22 and 2025–26 school years. According to Tom Kane, faculty director of the Harvard University Center for Education Policy Research, these findings account for roughly half of the learning loss observed in the United States between 2013 and the COVID-19 pandemic. Unlike previous studies that relied on school-level averages, this research utilized student-level data, allowing for a more precise analysis of how bans affect students across different achievement levels.
Beyond academic gains, the study highlights that cellphone bans are a cost-effective intervention. Researchers estimated that equipping a classroom of 17 students with lockable storage pouches costs approximately $425 per teacher. In comparison, the cost of funding an extra week of an average teacher’s salary is roughly $2,080.
Investigating Out-of-School Usage
While the in-school findings are clear, researchers are now turning their attention to the impact of cellphone and social media use outside the classroom. Kane noted that while in-school bans showed consistent benefits across various age groups, they did not fully explain the remaining learning loss. He suggests that out-of-school usage may be a significant factor, though testing this hypothesis has historically been difficult due to the lack of controlled environments outside of school.
Researchers are now looking toward a $17.1 billion settlement reached this summer between Meta and nearly every US state. The settlement requires Meta to implement strict usage limits for users under 18, which are expected to roll out in the coming months. Kane told The Verge that this development offers a unique opportunity to study the effects of reduced social media exposure on academic performance.
Challenges and Future Research
Despite the potential of the Meta settlement, there are significant hurdles to conducting this research. It remains unclear whether teens will actually reduce their total screen time or simply migrate to other platforms like TikTok or YouTube. Furthermore, researchers would need access to de-identified, aggregated data from these platforms to link usage patterns to specific student outcomes.
Kane emphasized the importance of gathering empirical evidence rather than relying on common assumptions regarding technology and mental health. He noted that while many parents and educators believe social media is a primary driver of learning loss, some of these theories may prove incorrect once data is analyzed.
“Now that we’ve learned something about the effect of in-school phone use, it makes it even more frustrating how little we know about the actual impact of out-of-school phone use,” Kane told The Verge. He advocates for using the 10-year window of the Meta settlement to build a robust evidence base, noting that the current restrictions are based on projections that have yet to be proven effective.








