Table of Contents
The recent International Court of Justice (ICJ) verdict making Myanmar the first country found guilty of committing genocide does more than deliver justice for Rohingya victims. Legal experts note that the decision also gives the 1948 genocide convention new relevance in governing state actions worldwide.
Applying the Genocide Convention
In a nine votes to six majority ruling, the panel of judges in The Hague established a clear roadmap for applying the convention to real-world scenarios where governments face accusations of genocide against entire population groups. Philippe Sands, a human rights lawyer on the Gambian legal team, stated to World news | The Guardian that the judgment brings the genocide convention alive and gives it practical meaning. Agnès Callamard, Amnesty International’s secretary general, described the decision as a rare moment of justice for survivors and their families, while Dr Iva Vukušić, a war crimes expert at Utrecht University, called it a positive development for international law.
The lengthy judgment will be examined closely by Israel, which is currently before the ICJ on genocide accusations, and by Germany, facing a case brought by Nicaragua regarding Gaza. The ruling may also serve as a benchmark for sister tribunals at the International Criminal Court (ICC). The Trump administration has previously expressed skepticism toward international legal institutions, with the US ambassador to the UN cautioning the court against lowering the legal threshold for proving genocide.
Examining Intent and Evidence
The court maintained the existing benchmark that genocidal intent must be the only reasonable inference from a state’s actions. Unlike previous cases involving Serbia, where the court cleared Belgrade of direct genocide, the new judgment finds the Myanmar military directly responsible for atrocities against the Rohingya minority during its 2017 campaign.
When evaluating the case, the court examined the entire targeted Rohingya population of 815,000 in northern Rakhine state, alongside the death toll of roughly 10,000. The judges also considered mental damage, sexual violence, and reproductive impacts. Crucially, the court determined that while Myanmar may have had motives like displacement or punishment, those motivations could exist alongside genocidal intent, establishing that such intent was the only reasonable inference from the totality of evidence.
Implications for the Gaza Case
International law experts highlight that the factors cited by the court closely parallel elements present in the ongoing Gaza case. The judges noted the targeting of children—pointing to the deaths of up to 2,109 Rohingya children under five—and condemned large-scale terrain clearance and rapid construction following village destruction. William Schabas, an international law professor at Middlesex University, told World news | The Guardian that the ruling is full of messages for Israel, noting that substituting the name Myanmar with Israel leaves much of the legal reasoning intact.
Although six dissenting votes indicate that aspects of the majority reasoning remain disputed, lawyers involved in the proceedings emphasize that a dismissal of the Myanmar case would have effectively ended South Africa’s legal challenge against Israel. Written pleadings in the Gaza case continue and are expected to last for at least three more years.








