Technology

Can AI really help spot Black Friday deals? We put it to the test

Can AI really help spot Black Friday deals? We put it to the test
Table of Contents
  1. Current AI Shopping Habits
  2. Testing the Chatbots
  3. Inconsistent Pricing and Limited Views

Black Friday brings endless online choices and promotional offers, leaving many shoppers overwhelmed while trying to find genuine bargains. Generative artificial intelligence products like ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini have promised to assist, prompting a test of free AI versions a week ahead of the shopping event.

Current AI Shopping Habits

Data indicates that relatively few UK shoppers currently turn to artificial intelligence for shopping assistance. A recent YouGov survey across 19 countries placed the UK second-last in the proportion of respondents who reported using AI to help them shop. Notably, 36% of respondents planning to shop around Black Friday stated they did not intend to use an AI tool.

Despite low current usage, the survey indicated growing consideration among consumers, prompting tech firms to release new features. Amazon introduced Alexa for Shopping for UK users in November, while OpenAI launched a Shopping Research tool on ChatGPT shortly before last year’s Black Friday. In the United States, Google recently rolled out Universal Cart, incorporating AI-powered features such as price tracking and promo code identification.

Testing the Chatbots

Testing four popular free AI models to find a 55-inch TV deal produced mixed results. OpenAI’s ChatGPT offered four options, starting with a Hisense TV on Joybuy for £499 down from £649. Its “best safer purchase” recommendation was the same Hisense model at full price from John Lewis and Richer Sounds, but clicking the links revealed the item was no longer listed online. A fourth option for a TCL TV exceeded the budget and was unavailable online, while an ad offered an OLED LG TV for £1,100.

Claude delivered the shortest response without detailed specifications, relying on a small number of online reviews. It recommended two TCL TVs, but the links led to dead pages on Richer Sounds and year-old deal round-ups. Claude expressed a lack of enthusiasm for other options due to scarce independent reviews, and mentioned two Samsung models while advising against buying them.

Gemini presented a table comparing four different models without store links, requiring manual searches. While the prices for one TCL TV were accurate at £649, it was sold out at one retailer, and another TCL model priced at £539 was £60 more expensive when checked at Currys. Gemini also included two Samsung models to avoid due to lower screen specifications.

Alexa returned four TVs based on Amazon’s own store inventory, recommending a Samsung model at £616 based on picture quality and customer ratings. While all stated prices were accurate, Alexa acknowledged it only searches Amazon and encouraged checking rivals for better guarantees and prices.

Inconsistent Pricing and Limited Views

Advanced methods, such as utilizing ChatGPT’s agentic AI mode, can yield different results. Tech journalist Alex Hughes used agentic AI during last year’s Black Friday to find a TV over a 20-minute automated search, though he ultimately purchased a model for a lower price at a physical store. Hughes stated he would likely not use AI for Black Friday deals again, noting that live price data remains inconsistent and frequently incorrect.

Naureen Mohammed, an advisor on how businesses appear in AI results, told BBC News that consumers only see a partial picture when talking to chatbots. When businesses fail to update their prices, older prices are served as current deals. Mohammed’s analysis of UK tech deals indicated large retailers dominated results, with Amazon appearing in half of responses.

Consumer group Which? reported that inaccurate pricing in AI results increases the workload for deal hunters. Senior researcher Hannah Walsh told BBC News that inaccurate price lists waste significant time and risk causing shoppers to miss out on suitable models within their budgets.

You May Also Like

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *