Table of Contents
A new study suggests that placing students’ phones in locked pouches during the school day may help restore historic learning losses in reading and math. The research indicates that strict cellphone bans could recover about half of the learning time U.S. students have lost since 2013.
Study Findings on Cellphone Bans
Tom Kane of Harvard University, a co-author of the new study reported by NPR, stated that U.S. students began losing two to three weeks of learning each year around 2013. He explained that strict cellphone bans seem to plug about half of that leak, which equates to one to two weeks of learning annually.
Douglas Staiger of Dartmouth College, another co-author, noted that these gains could accumulate over time, much like the initial declines did. The research represents the first nationwide analysis of student-level math and reading test scores before and after schools implemented locked-pouch cellphone bans, conducted jointly by Harvard’s Center for Education Policy Research, Dartmouth, and testing organization NWEA.
The research team examined a national sample of more than 3 million elementary, middle, and high school students across five school years, comparing test scores in schools with phone pouches to similar schools without them. According to the researchers, the learning gains appeared to persist and continue year after year for up to three years following adoption.
Comparing Previous Research Results
The latest findings come with caveats, as a separate peer-reviewed study from April found that these pouches had close to zero impact on student test scores. Brian Jacob, a co-author of the April study and a professor of education policy at the University of Michigan, stated that they did not find evidence of meaningful achievement gains overall.
The two studies differed in methodology, with the April study examining school-level mean test scores across thousands of schools using Yondr pouches, while the newer study utilized individual student-level scores from 844 schools. However, Jacob acknowledged that the new study is encouraging if the benefits truly persist over time.
Tom Dee, a Stanford University education professor and co-author of the April study, expressed caution about extrapolating small estimates based on only a few years of bans. Conversely, Kane argued that the pouches make financial sense for schools because the cost of roughly $25 per student is far less than paying teachers for extra weeks of instruction.
Timeline of Student Achievement Declines
Student math and reading achievement rose steadily from 1990 until 2013, before beginning a sustained downward trend that preceded the COVID-19 pandemic. Stanford University researcher Sean Reardon previously told NPR that reading scores declined for four to six years before the pandemic without any distinct pandemic effect visible in the decade of data.
The new research adds to arguments that the mass adoption of smartphones by children and teens contributed to these score drops. In 2011, fewer than a quarter of teen students had smartphones, but by 2018, 95% did, aligning with similar student achievement declines in other industrialized nations.
Kane stated that his next research focus will involve studying how students use smartphones and social media outside of school hours.








