Politics

Justice Secretary Calls for Ban on Rape Myths in Trials

Justice Secretary Calls for Ban on Rape Myths in Trials

The justice secretary has called for new rules to prevent barristers from using rape myths to defend their clients following the Russell Brand trial. As first reported by the Times, Alex Norris wrote a letter to the Bar Standards Board (BSB) stating it was unacceptable to perpetuate myths about victims in court and warning that disciplinary action could be taken against those who do so.

Trial Remarks and Official Reactions

During his closing speech in the trial, Brand’s defence barrister, Ian Winter KC, questioned why his client’s accusers had not fought back. Brand was sentenced to ten-and-a-half years in prison for one count of rape and three counts of sexual assault. Winter noted to the court that none of the accusers resisted, screamed, or tried to leave, and asked the jury if they could be sure that out of the many women Brand had sex with over a decade, he raped only three.

Norris wrote in his letter that the board must send a strong signal to the profession regarding the harm caused by rape myths, adding that their continuation in a courtroom is unacceptable just as they are in wider society. The charity Rape Crisis stated that it is very common for survivors of sexual violence to find themselves unable to move or speak.

The judge presiding over the case, Mr Justice Bennathan, was praised by the Criminal Bar Association and campaign groups for addressing the issue during his sentencing remarks at Southwark Crown Court. He told Brand that regardless of what women wear, where they go, or what they drink, they retain the right to say no and demand justice when sexual predators act without consent.

Debate Over Regulations and Training

A spokesperson for the BSB stated that such cases must be decided on evidence rather than prejudice, warning that any other approach might discourage victims from coming forward and damage public confidence in the criminal justice system. The board added that it had set up an expert group this year to advise on strengthening standards for barristers.

Kirsty Brimelow KC, chair of the Bar Council of England and Wales, told BBC Radio 4’s Woman’s Hour that it was important for the BSB to remain independent of the government. She noted that a regulatory gap had not been demonstrated and that existing powers to discipline barristers for code breaches already exist. Brimelow cautioned that while training for vulnerable witnesses is ongoing, making it mandatory could be problematic and might push more barristers away from defending rape and sexual assault cases amid an existing shortage.

A Ministry of Justice spokesperson said the justice secretary is determined to maximize protections for victims, emphasizing that rape myths have no place in courts and that victims must never feel as though they are on trial. Metropolitan Police Commissioner Sir Mark Rowley stated in a BBC interview earlier this month that some trial comments approached victim blaming, and he supported law changes requiring judges to direct juries on rape misconceptions in every rape trial.

Prime Minister Andy Burnham stated that the government must ensure rape victims do not feel like they are on trial.

You May Also Like

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *