Table of Contents
Congress has six years to enact changes to Social Security to prevent cuts to retirement benefits. Senators elected in the Nov. 3 midterms will be in office when the deadline arrives, and their decisions may be critical in making tax changes that can affect Social Security.
Social Security Funding Pressures
During the midterm campaign season, tax policy surfaced in the debate over Social Security in two different ways. Many Democrats, and some Republicans, called for high earners to pay more in Social Security payroll taxes, while many Republicans touted a recently enacted tax deduction for adults 65 and older. The diverging tactics come at a crucial moment for reform, as the first approach could increase revenue flowing into the program, while the second reduces eligible older adults’ income taxes and can lower the taxes some beneficiaries pay on Social Security benefits, thereby reducing program revenue.
Social Security trustees’ latest projections show the trust fund used to pay retirement benefits may start to become depleted in 2032, when 78% of benefits would be payable. Lawmakers do have some leeway, because if the program’s retirement and disability trust funds are combined, depletion would be pushed out to 2034, when 83% of scheduled benefits would be payable. However, that still represents a reduction for retirees coming in the near future.
“We’ve waited too long already, and the consequences are that the gap has grown larger,” Shai Akabas, vice president of economic policy at the Bipartisan Policy Center, told US Top News and Analysis of Social Security’s shortfall.
Debate Over Payroll Taxes for High Earners
On the campaign trail, midterm candidates largely avoided specifics on how they would reform Social Security, but raising the payroll tax cap was a popular choice among Democratic candidates. That change would require individuals earning more than the cap, currently set at $184,500, to begin contributing payroll taxes for their earnings above that threshold. In 2026, workers and employers each contribute 6.2% of pay up to that cap, while self-employed individuals pay 12.4%. The wage cap will rise in 2027 to $192,300, adjusting higher annually to reflect incremental changes in the average wage index.
Following the election, Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., who is expected to become the next chair of the Social Security subcommittee, stated on X on Nov. 7 that his proposal to increase benefits by at least $2,400 per year and scrap the cap on earnings subject to Social Security taxes would be a top priority. Outgoing Sen. Bill Cassidy, R-La., responded on X that the plan would put a 12.4% tax on people who are not millionaires or billionaires. Meanwhile, a national survey fielded in February by the University of Maryland School of Public Policy found that 79% of respondents support raising taxes for wages over $400,000.
Some experts note that Congress may put off tax hikes that could prove politically unpopular. “I think lawmakers may put some of these taxes on the table closer to 2032, when the Social Security trust fund hits insolvency,” Jessica Riedl, a fellow at the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center, told US Top News and Analysis, adding that Washington officials tend to wait until the last minute. Riedl noted that lifting the payroll tax cap from just under $200,000 to $300,000 in annual earnings would cost someone at that higher income threshold about $6,700 more in direct payroll taxes.
According to a September analysis by the Social Security Administration, eliminating the cap starting in 2027 with no benefit credit for earnings above the current threshold would eliminate 58% of the long-range actuarial balance over 75 years. Applying the 12.4% rate to earnings over $250,000 could address 57% of the balance, while applying it to earnings over $400,000 would eliminate 53% of the balance, provided there are no benefit increases in exchange for extra contributions. Conversely, William McBride, chief economist at the Tax Foundation, cautioned that raising the cap would be an unprecedented increase in marginal tax rates that could add more than 12 percentage points to the cost of earning an additional dollar of wages, potentially affecting the labor market and leading to higher unemployment.
Senior Tax Deductions and Solvency Concerns
On the other side of the debate, some Republican candidates campaigned on extending a temporary senior tax deduction of up to $6,000 per eligible individual that is set to expire in 2028. This deduction, part of the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA) passed in July of the previous year, is in effect for tax years 2025 through 2028. The measure provides a deduction reducing seniors’ taxable income regardless of whether they have claimed Social Security benefits, unlike proposals to entirely eliminate taxes on benefits.
When President Donald Trump signed OBBBA into law in 2025, the White House stated in a release that no tax on Social Security is a reality. Congressional Democrats unanimously opposed OBBBA due to provisions including cuts to Medicaid and food assistance. McBride at the Tax Foundation explained that the senior deduction affects lower- and middle-income taxpayers to a greater degree, whereas eliminating taxes on Social Security benefits would benefit upper-income taxpayers more.
Under current rules, individuals with $25,000 to $34,000 in combined income pay federal taxes on up to 50% of their Social Security benefits, while those with over $34,000 face taxes on up to 85% of their benefits. For married couples filing jointly, combined incomes between $32,000 and $44,000 subject up to 50% of benefits to tax, and amounts over $44,000 subject up to 85% of benefits to tax. The senior bonus tax deduction allows individuals aged 65 and older to deduct up to $6,000, or up to $12,000 for married couples, with the deduction phasing out for modified adjusted gross incomes over $75,000 for single filers and $150,000 for married couples.
According to administration figures, OBBBA ensures that 88% of beneficiaries age 65 and older will have exemptions and deductions exceeding their taxable Social Security income, up from 64% prior to the law. However, the measure does not resolve Social Security’s depletion problem. In an annual report released in June, Social Security’s trustees cited OBBBA as having a substantial effect on the program’s financial status because beneficiaries will pay less in income taxes, moving the projected depletion date for the retirement trust fund up one quarter to the fourth quarter of 2032.








