Economy

The Booming Merchant Cash Advance Industry Trap in the US

The Booming Merchant Cash Advance Industry Trap in the US

A California entrepreneur’s seven-year legal battle against a funding company highlights the risks of the rapidly growing merchant cash advance industry in the United States. Vahe Shahinian, who ran an event ticketing and concert production company, alleges he fell victim to fraud after seeking funding to support his expanding business.

A Fateful Deal and a Disappearing Line of Credit

Before his financial troubles began, Shahinian had operated his company, It’s My Seat, for 15 years. Trained as an aerospace engineer, he built the ticketing platform into his primary source of income, eventually branching out into producing and promoting concert tours. When planning his largest tour yet in 2018, Shahinian sought his fifth round of short-term merchant funding from American Express, but the company declined, as it was phasing out the program.

Facing a strict two-week deadline to secure about $200,000 for tour expenses, Shahinian turned to merchant cash advances, or MCAs. MCAs provide fast cash in exchange for a percentage of future sales, but they often carry annualized rates between 25% and 200% and operate with virtually no regulatory oversight because they are legally classified as purchases of future sales rather than loans. After taking two cash advances totaling $250,000, Shahinian wiped out his profits paying them back.

Seeking a sustainable financial option, Shahinian was subsequently approached by a broker offering a line of credit worth up to $750,000 at a 9% annual interest rate. The broker instructed him to accept an initial smaller amount and make 30 days of daily payments of $3,600 to demonstrate dependability before accessing the full line of credit. Shahinian agreed, receiving $228,000 after fees were withheld.

After 40 days of consistent daily payments, the line of credit never materialized, and Shahinian’s bank account reached zero. The Wall Street-based funding firm, EIN Cap, later argued in court that it never promised loans or lines of credit, but rather delivered an MCA, adding that intermediaries arranged the deal. Shahinian’s lawyer, Shane Heskin, describes this deceptive practice as “carroting,” where borrowers are lured in with low-interest loan offers only to receive an unsolicited MCA.

To keep his concert tours afloat, Shahinian took out more cash advances, exhausted his credit cards, and tapped home equity from himself, his parents, and a friend, ultimately accumulating more than $1 million in personal debts. As bills mounted, he defaulted on payments, faced collection notices, and lost his home of 16 years to foreclosure. He ultimately had to sell his belongings, pack up his computers and sound system, and move back into his childhood bedroom with his elderly parents at age 51.

Unlike many borrowers who cannot afford legal representation or choose to settle, Shahinian chose to fight. He sued EIN Cap and the brokers in 2019, later settling with the brokers and focusing his remaining U.S. District Court lawsuit in Los Angeles on fraud claims against EIN. Levi Silver, counsel for EIN, stated in an email that the firm denies Shahinian’s claims and that its position is outlined in public court filings.

During his investigation, Shahinian discovered that the broker who introduced himself as Bryan Stein used multiple names and had a criminal record, having pleaded guilty to grand larceny in 2012, according to the Brooklyn District Attorney’s Office. Shahinian also tracked down roughly 700 business owners who had been sued by EIN for debt collection, connecting with about 70 of them.

Court records show that over the past decade, EIN has faced several lawsuits across at least nine states, mostly related to borrower bankruptcies that were settled or dismissed. However, in other rulings, judges have penalized the firm; last year, a federal judge in Illinois ordered EIN to return over $184,000 in profits after finding the company prolonged a Ponzi scheme by failing to conduct proper due diligence.

While a handful of states, including California, have introduced new disclosure requirements for MCA companies, and California recently passed a law mandating licensing and background checks for funders and brokers starting in 2028, these measures arrive too late for Shahinian’s business. He has scaled his operations back to basic ticketing and marketing software development while awaiting his trial, which has been delayed multiple times. He hopes his lawsuit will help him recover over $5 million in accrued debt, interest, and fees while inspiring other trapped business owners to stand up against predatory funding practices.

You May Also Like

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *