The Federal Communications Commission instructed California to halt the enforcement of its Carrier of Last Resort (COLR) rules against AT&T. This directive establishes a fresh conflict between the Trump administration and California regarding the authority of the state to enforce its own telecommunications regulations.
AT&T Service Discontinuation Plans
As a Carrier of Last Resort in California, AT&T must provide telephone service to any prospective customer within its designated territory. The company aims to halt basic phone service offerings to new customers while terminating service for 184,000 residential customers and 15,000 business customers by June 1, 2027.
The newly released FCC order approved AT&T’s request to preempt state regulations, building upon a prior commission approval of the company’s service discontinuation petition. AT&T previously pursued a similar outcome through the judicial system, though a federal judge dismissed its request to bypass California regulations in July.
The federal order likely does not settle the matter entirely, as the state retains the option to initiate legal action against the commission. California remains unique in its resistance against AT&T, given that the company has secured relief from COLR obligations across 20 out of the 21 states comprising its wireline service territory.
Federal and State Perspectives on Modernization
FCC Chairman Brendan Carr noted in a statement accompanying the order that California’s framework may have been appropriate three decades ago, but the regulations belong to a past era and no longer fit the current competitive and advanced marketplace.
Should AT&T terminate service across its traditional copper lines, numerous residences and commercial entities will not receive modern fiber network installations. AT&T maintains that a cellular-connected wireless home phone alternative will suffice, and the commission concurred with this assessment.
Carr stated that the commission approved AT&T applications to substitute legacy voice services with contemporary IP-based alternatives in specific regional zones, while state mandates currently obstruct the federally authorized transition.
Conversely, California contends that its regulations permit wireless substitutions provided they satisfy state criteria for basic telephone service, requiring AT&T to prove its wireless option fulfills COLR duties. State mandates mandate flat-rate options for unlimited voice calls, reduced Lifeline pricing for qualified low-income consumers, and telecommunications relay services for individuals who are deaf or hard of hearing.








