Technology

Tim Hortons App Criticised Over Data Sharing With Forter

Tim Hortons App Criticised Over Data Sharing With Forter
Table of Contents
  1. Data Collection and Privacy Concerns
  2. Links to Israeli Military Intelligence
  3. Regulatory Gaps and Calls for Inquiry

The popular Canadian coffeehouse chain Tim Hortons is facing a strong public backlash following revelations that its mobile app sends sensitive user data to an Israeli cybertech company. Canadians for Justice and Peace in the Middle East (CPJME) disclosed that the app shares information with Forter, raising significant concerns among consumers and digital rights advocates regarding privacy and third-party data access.

Data Collection and Privacy Concerns

The disclosures follow an earlier investigation by Canadian broadcaster CBC into the data practices of popular domestic apps. Al Jazeera independently confirmed that the Tim Hortons app transmits user data to Forter, which Tim Hortons previously told CBC is a fraud-prevention measure. However, experts have criticised the scope of the information gathered.

Joel Reardon, a computer science professor at the University of Calgary whose research supported the CBC investigation, told Al Jazeera that the data collection happens before consent is given and appears excessive. Reardon explained that upon launch, the app sends unique identifiers, sensor details, and nearby Wi-Fi network names to the third-party firm. This information allows Forter to generate a persistent digital fingerprint for each device.

Matt Hatfield, executive director of the digital rights organisation OpenMedia, told Al Jazeera that customers use the app simply to purchase coffee rather than export their location indicators to foreign entities. Hatfield noted that many corporations quietly pass consumer information through long chains of unseen vendors.

CPJME warned that the practice creates massive digital footprints without adequate consumer awareness, channelling data to an opaque Israeli firm. Jason Toney, CJPME’s media advocacy director, told Al Jazeera that Forter’s technology primarily protects wealthy corporations from reimbursement costs rather than ordinary consumers.

Legal and privacy experts also highlighted issues surrounding informed consent. Johanna Gunawan, an assistant professor of computer science and law at Maastricht University, told Al Jazeera that lengthy privacy policies impose an unbalanced cognitive load on consumers, leaving them largely unaware of how their data is handled.

Beyond the scope of data collection, CPJME raised concerns regarding Forter’s founders—Michael Reitblat, Liron Damri, and Alon Shemesh—who have been reported as alumni of the Israeli military’s Unit 8200 signals intelligence and cyberwarfare division. According to reports from The Times of Israel and The Jerusalem Post, the company’s technology has ties to Israeli military intelligence.

Unit 8200 has previously faced scrutiny regarding its use of cloud platforms for mass surveillance of Palestinians and its association with Lavender, an artificial intelligence system used to generate targeting lists during the war in Gaza. While Toney noted these connections are concerning, he acknowledged there is no evidence that Forter misuses data collected specifically from the Tim Hortons app.

Al Jazeera was unable to confirm whether Forter still uses Israeli military intelligence or if its data remains accessible to Israeli state agencies. Tim Hortons, its parent company Restaurant Brands International (RBI), and Forter did not respond to Al Jazeera’s requests for comment prior to publication.

Regulatory Gaps and Calls for Inquiry

Tim Hortons previously faced legal trouble over data tracking in 2022, when privacy commissioners found the app illegally tracked user locations while closed. Because Canadian federal privacy laws lack enforcement mechanisms for financial penalties, the company faced no fines at the time.

Hatfield described Canada’s federal private-sector privacy legislation, PIPEDA, as outdated, noting it allows companies to transfer data to service providers without explicit consumer consent provided the company remains accountable. He added that proposed new privacy legislation, Bill C-36, would introduce financial penalties and impact assessments but would still permit unconsented data transfers to service providers under certain conditions.

CPJME is now calling for a formal inquiry by the Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada into how Tim Hortons handles consumer data, while also criticising the CBC for omitting Forter’s identity from its initial broadcast. Hatfield urged Tim Hortons to publicly disclose every third-party recipient of its app data, specify storage locations, and clarify access rights.

You May Also Like

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *