Environment

EPA’s Chemical-Detecting Plane Faces Growing Scrutiny

EPA’s Chemical-Detecting Plane Faces Growing Scrutiny
Table of Contents
  1. A History of Rapid Aerial Detection
  2. Staff Departures and Institutional Knowledge Loss
  3. Concerns Over Recent Disaster Responses
  4. Sensor Replacements and Future Uncertainty

The United States Environmental Protection Agency’s specialized chemical-detecting aircraft, known as ASPECT, has seen its emergency deployments drop significantly in recent years. Once a critical tool for scanning hazardous air during major industrial disasters, the single-engine Cessna has responded to just seven emergencies since early 2021.

A History of Rapid Aerial Detection

The program was originally created by the Department of Defense as Airborne Spectral Photometric Environmental Collection Technology before being transferred to the EPA. For over two decades, the plane flew into many of the nation’s severe disasters, including New Orleans following Hurricane Katrina, the Deepwater Horizon oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico, and a 2019 chemical storage fire near Houston.

Richard Lawhorn, an assistant chief with Harris County’s hazardous materials response team in Texas, stated that the aircraft could identify chemicals at elevations beyond ground crews and survey a much broader area quickly. Unlike ground monitors, the plane can scan a swath of air three-quarters of a mile wide, capturing a far wider picture of potential hazards.

Staff Departures and Institutional Knowledge Loss

Former program staff explained that the decline began with departures during Donald Trump’s first administration, when the EPA ordered personnel to relocate to Texas or face termination in 2019. Mark Thomas, a former EPA official who managed the effort, retired rather than move, while other key specialists also left the division.

According to former scientists, the agency failed to fill those vacancies with staff experienced in airborne chemical detection, leading to a loss of institutional knowledge. While the plane averaged roughly four emergency missions per year during its first two decades, it has flown an average of just one per year over the past five years, missing numerous chemical emergencies across the country.

Concerns Over Recent Disaster Responses

Former ASPECT scientists stated that recent missions, including the 2023 train derailment in East Palestine, Ohio, and the 2025 fire at Smitty’s Supply in Louisiana, were badly mismanaged. In East Palestine, the plane was not requested until more than two days after the initial derailment and collected just eight minutes of chemical data. An EPA inspector general investigation later revealed that the agency poorly documented procedures and failed to inform responders properly about the plane’s capabilities.

During the fire at Smitty’s Supply in Roseland, Louisiana, the EPA declared the air safe after flights, but former ASPECT scientist Robert Kroutil later found high concentrations of toxic chemicals that the agency had missed. Kroutil analyzed raw flight data by hand because the plane could no longer identify chemicals within minutes, a process that now takes about a week.

Sensor Replacements and Future Uncertainty

The EPA stated that the plane’s chemical sensors are wearing out and expects replacements from Canadian company Telops to be working by mid-2027. However, five individuals who helped build and run the program told Floodlight that the EPA is fixing the wrong problem, warning that the new sensors will be slower, less sensitive, and less capable of detecting hazardous chemicals during complex industrial emergencies.

Kroutil retired out of frustration with how officials were running the division, leaving behind a program that critics fear is no longer equipped to protect the public during chemical crises.

You May Also Like

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *